As a result of the equalization of the profitability of capitals (which is associated with the formation of a surplus of commodities and production), with the constancy of the volume of circulating money (which maintains the constancy of the price level), as a result of the selective inclusion of consumption requests in the market, in a certain interval of the ratio of satisfied demand to total supply, there is observed, due to a number of reasons that prevent the reduction of prices, the stabilization of the prices of final commodities in relation to their value, their maintenance in equilibrium even with some redistribution of satisfied demand between goods. Continuing the logic of marginalism, we must conclude that the partial marginal utilities of less rare commodities, through the limitation of their consumption, are necessarily equated with the marginal utility of the rarer commodity, which has unaccounted consequences. The «laws of supply and demand» (where price is not defined as a concept [1, p.24]) are incompatible with the theory of marginal utility, which means that price is a function of the amount of consumption, but not vice versa. The law of demand, in essence, asserts the tendency of the partial rarity of a commodity, due to the growth of purchases, to its market rarity without observing marginal ratios. The assertion that when the price rises, it is advantageous to increase production, is inconsistent with the marginal position that the price rises with an increase in the scarcity of the commodity, which corresponds to a decrease in the amount of utilities that go into income. The dependence of demand on price is consistent with the labor theory of value.
value, price, money, consumption demands, marginal utility, rate of profit, demand, supply, surplus value
1. Nekipelov A.D., Krizis v ekonomicheskoy nauke - priroda i puti preodoleniya, Vestnik rossiyskoy akademii nauk, 2019, tom 89, № 1, DOI:https://doi.org/10.7868/S0869587300000-00, s.24, 26, 32, 33
2. Polterovich V.M. (1998). Krizis ekonomicheskoy teorii // Ekonomicheskie nauki sovremennoy Rossii. № 1. S. 46-66, s.47, 49
3. Polterovich V.M. (2011). Stanovlenie obschego social'nogo analiza // Obschestvennye nauki i sovremennost'. № 2. S. 101-111, s.6, 9
4. Hudokormov A.G. (vyp.1 2021). Novye dannye o «tret'em krizise» ekonomiks // Voprosy politicheskoy ekonomii. № 1 (25). S. 103-125, s.105, 107 DOI:https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4666161 (https://zenodo.org/record/4666161)
5. Avtonomov V. S., Metodologicheskie problemy sovremennoy ekonomicheskoy nauki, Vestnik rossiyskoy akademii nauk, 2006, tom 76, № 3, s. 203-208
6. Biryukov V. V. «Neoklassicheskiy tupik v razrabotke teorii stoimosti i osobennosti issledovatel'skoy paradigmy klassicheskoy shkoly», Zhurnal «Teoreticheskaya ekonomika» №9, 2021 www.theoreticaleconomy.ru
7. Vodomerov N.K. «Put' k podlinnomu znaniyu – kriticheskoe otnoshenie k «modelyam» tak nazyvaemogo «Mainstream» i priznanie marksistskoy politekonomii v kachestve osnovy ekonomicheskih issledovaniy», zhurnal «Teoreticheskaya ekonomika» №6, 2012
8. Vodomerov N.K. «O neobhodimosti i osnovah sozdaniya al'ternativnogo kursa makroekonomiki», zhurnal «Teoreticheskaya ekonomika» №2, 2013, s.7-23
9. Balackiy E.V. Mirovaya ekonomicheskaya nauka na sovremennom etape: krizis ili proryv? // Naukovedenie. - 2001. - № 2. - S. 68-72. - URL: http://vivovoco.astronet.ru/VV/PAPERS/ECCE/BALA.HTM
10. Balysheva O.M. (2012). Diskussiya o krizise v ekonomicheskoy teorii // Problemy sovremennoy ekonomiki. № 41. S. 60-62.
11. Shlychkov V.V., Nestulaeva D.R. (2013). Krizis ekonomicheskoy teorii kak otpravnaya tochka ee dal'neyshego razvitiya // Vestnik ekonomiki, prava i sociologii. № 4. S. 95-98.
12. Gelbreyt Dzh.K. Tretiy krizis v ekonomicheskoy nauke, Mir peremen, 2013 № 1, S.24-28
13. Davar E., Krizis ekonomicheskoy nauki: prichiny i vyhod, Terra Ecanomicus, 2015 tom 13 №2, s.73
14. Sraffa P. Proizvodstvo tovarov posredstvom tovarov. - M., Direktmedia Pablishing, 2008
15. Ronkaliya A. «Sraffianskaya revolyuciya» // Ekonomicheskaya mysl' zapada // Sovremennaya ekonomicheskaya mysl', M., Progress-1981
16. Grodskiy V.S. Ekonomiks zavershenie «spora dvuh Kembridzhey», monografiya, –Moskva: RIOR INFRA M., 2021, – 323 s. – (Nauchnaya mysl'). – DOI:https//doi.org/10.29039/02029-6, s.115-116
17. Menger K. Osnovaniya politicheskoy ekonomii // Avstriyskaya shkola v politicheskoy ekonomii. K. Menger, E. Bem-Baverk, F. Vizer. M.: Ekonomika, 1992. S. 31–242. Per. s nem. G. Tiktina i I. Aberguza pod red. R. M. Orzhenckogo, s.162
18. Dzhevons, Uil'yam Stenli, Teoriya politicheskoy ekonomii (s prilozheniem «Uchebnika politicheskoy ekonomii») / U. S. Dzhevons ; per. s angl. N. V. Avtonomovoy. —Moskva; Chelyabinsk : Socium, 2021. — 477 s. — ISBN978-5-91603-144-7, s.43, 60, 81, 112, 127, 129, 151, 152, 154, 189, 194, 196, 203, 205, 206, 210-216, 283
19. Marks K., Engel's F., Soch., 2-e izd., t.23, s. 124, 170, 185, 169, 244, 605
20. Marks K., Engel's F., Soch., 2-e izd., t.24, s.128, 406
21. Marks K., Engel's F., Soch., 2-e izd., T. 25, ch.1, s.168-218
22. Marks K., Engel's F., Soch., 2-e izd., T. 25, ch.2
23. Kurs politicheskoy ekonomii. V 2-h t.1 Pod red. N. L. Cagolova. Ucheb, posobie dlya e.kon. vuzov i fak. Izd. 3-e, pererabot. i dop. M., «Ekonomika», 1973, T.1, s.158
24. Dokinz R., Egoistichnyy gen, Per. s angl. – M.: Mir, 1993 –318s., s.176-186, 187-212, 216-230
25. Dokinz R., «Rasshirennyy fenotip Dal'nee vliyanie gena», besplatnaya elektronnaya biblioteka BooksCafe.Net
26. Marshall A. Principy politicheskoy ekonomii. T. I. Per. s angl, - M., ’’Progress”, 1984 - 23 l. («Ekonomicheskaya mysl' Zapada”. Dlya nauchnyh bibliotek), s.53, 120, 164, 257-258, 320-322
27. Marshall A. Principy politicheskoy ekonomii. T. II. Per. s angl, - M., ’’Progress”, 1984 - 23 l. («Ekonomicheskaya mysl' Zapada”. Dlya nauchnyh bibliotek), s.22, 24, 26
28. Marshall A. Principy politicheskoy ekonomii. T. III. Per. s angl, - M., ’’Progress”, 1984 - 23 l. («Ekonomicheskaya mysl' Zapada”. Dlya nauchnyh bibliotek), s.19, 166, 219
29. Dolan E. Dzh., Lindsey D. «Rynok: mikroekonomicheskaya model'», S.-Pb., 1992– 496 s., s.290, 291
30. Pol A. Samuel'son, Vil'yam D. Nordhaus, Ekonomika: Per. s angl. – M.: «Izdatel'stvo BINOM», 1997, – 800s., s.119, 143
31. Rossinskiy, V.P. Proverka polozheniy marzhinalizma / V.P. Rossinskiy.-DOIhttps://doi.org/10.52957/22213260_2022_12_32. - Tekst: elektronnyy // Teoreticheskaya ekonomika. - 2022 - №12. - S.32-44. - URL: http://www.theoreticaleconomy.ru (Data publikacii: 30.12.2022), s.33- 35
32. Hiks Dzh.R., Stoimost' i kapital: Per. s angl./Obsch. red. i vstup. st. R.M. Entova. — M., Izdatel'skaya gruppa «Progress», 1993 — 488 s. («Ekonomicheskaya mysl' Zapada»), s.103, 104
33. Keyns Dzh.M. «Izbrannye proizvedeniya» M., Ekonomika 1993, s. 239, 250, 241, 251
34. Vasil'ev E.P. «Agregirovannaya proizvodstvennaya funkciya («spor dvuh Kembridzhey»)» // Voprosy ekonomiki №6(138)-2006
35. Koen A., Harkurt Dzh. «Sud'ba diskussii dvuh Kembridzhey o teorii kapitala», Voprosy ekonomiki №8 2009
36. Rossinskiy V.P. «Obraschenie deneg i stoimostey v rynochnom proizvodstve kak sredstvo proverki ekonomicheskoy teorii» // www.theoreticaleconomy.ru, zhurnal «Teoreticheskaya ekonomika», №1 (73), Yaroslavl' 2021g., s. 21-24, 31, 32
37. Val'ras L. «Elementy chistoy politicheskoy ekonomii». – M.: Izograf, 2000g, s.126
38. Smit A. Issledovanie o prirode i prichinah bogatstva narodov. M.: Izdatel'stvo social'no – ekonomicheskoy literatury, 1962, s.260
39. Pfancagl' I., Teoriya izmereniy, izdatel'stvo «MIR» Moskva, 1976, s.11
40. Rossinskiy, V.P. K voprosu o raschete optovyh i roznichnyh cen na osnove zakona stoimosti i teorii trudovyh otnosheniy / V.P. Rossinskiy.- Tekst : elektronnyy // Teoreticheskaya ekonomika. - 2023 - №4. - S.32-44. - URL:http://www.theoreticaleconomy.ru (Data publikacii: 30.04.2023), s.50,51, 54
41. Kostyuk V.N. Istoriya ekonomicheskih ucheniy, M., Izdatel'stvo Centr, 1997, s.13
42. Bem-Baverk O. Kapital i procent; T.2: Pozitivnaya teoriya kapitala; T.3: Ekskursy /Oygen fon Bem-Baverk; per. s angl. V. Koshkina pod red. A. V. Kuryaeva. – Chelyabinsk: Socium, 2010. — 916 s., s.75
43. Bem-Baverk, Oygen fon, Izbrannye trudy o cennosti, procente i kapitale / Oygen fon Bem-Baverk; [predisl. I. A. Shumpeter; per. s nem. L. I. Forberta, A. Canina; per. s angl. N. V. Avtotomovoy; per. s lat. A. A. Rossiusa]. — M.: Eksmo, 2009. — 912 s. — (Antologiya ekonomicheskoy mysli), s.701
44. Shekli Robert, Bilet na planetu Tranay, rasskazy: http://klassikaknigi.info/robert-shekli-bilet-na-planetu-tranaj/
45. Klark Dzh. B. «Raspredelenie bogatstva», Leningrad, OGIZ, 1934 g.
46. Debre Zherar, Teoriya cennosti: Aksiomaticheskiy analiz ekonomicheskogo ravnovesiya / seriya «Akademicheskaya kniga», izdatel'skiy dom RANH i GS, Moskva 2018 g., s.59, 76
47. Elektronnyy resurs «Enciklopediya po ekonomike» https://economy-ru.info/info/68221/
48. Gerchikova I.N., Menedzhment, uchebnik, Vtoroe izdanie, pererabotannoe i dopolnennoe, Moskva, «Banki i birzhi», Izdatel'skoe ob'edinenie «YuNITI», 1995, s.121
49. Rossinskiy V.P. «Nekotorye ogranicheniya rostu deystvitel'nogo sprosa pri vedenii rasshirennogo vosproizvodstva v pole blagopriyatnyh estestvennyh zapasov» // Sibirskiy nauchnyy sbornik: ekonomicheskie nauki: sbornik nauchnyh trudov. Vypusk 1 / Pod obsch. red. S.S. Chernova. – Novosibirsk: Izdatel'stvo CRNS, 2017. – s5-29., s.23
50. Wicksell Knut «Interest and prices», The Ludwig von Mises Institute Auburn, Alabama 2007
51. Gil'ferding Rudol'f «Finansovyy kapital. Noveyshaya faza v razvitii kapitalizma», perevod s nemeckogo I. Stepanova, chetvertoe izdanie (stereotipnoe), Gosudarstvennoe izdatel'stvo Moskva, 1924.
52. Rossinskiy, V.P. Proverka polozheniy marzhinalizma / V.P. Rossinskiy.-DOIhttps://doi.org/10.52957/22213260_2022_12_32. - Tekst: elektronnyy // Teoreticheskaya ekonomika. - 2022 - №12. - S.32-44. - URL: http://www.theoreticaleconomy.ru (Data publikacii: 30.12.2022), s.37- 39
